The Voyage of the Dawn Treader – One Year Later
For the last few weeks, I’ve been meaning to mark the one-year anniversary of Dawn Treader hitting theaters by re-watching the film. I actually meant to do it on the one-year anniversary of when I personally saw the film, but since that was back in November, I got caught up in NaNo and Thanksgiving and it completely passed me by. So today, I was in the car riding home with nothing to do, so I decided to finally make good on that digital copy of the film I’ve been carrying around on my iPhone and iPod for the better part of the year, and watch the movie.
This actually was the first time I’ve seen the film since I hosted the Chicago Lion Party this very night a year ago. I’m still not sure why I hadn’t watched again it since then. I bought the DVD/Blu Ray combo pack the day it came out, and like I said, had the digital copy on various media devices at all times. I always meant to watch it, but I never got around to it. But why?
Maybe it was because of the bad taste that was still in my mouth from the weeks following the film’s release last year. I hated that Narniaweb was so bitterly divided over the film. While there were only a handful of people who loved this movie wholeheartedly, there were quite a few, including myself, who were able to separate the good parts from the bad and still come out of the movie screening feeling fairly satisfied. But I’m not one for conflict, and I didn’t feel like diving into discussing the film with many people who were very, very vocal in their complete disdain for this movie. So even though I liked it myself, I felt like the good feeling that I did have about it was becoming tarnished by all the negativity. So I subconsciously distanced myself away from it as much as I could, and just didn’t get involved. And that included watching the movie.
But today, I finally took the time to see the movie again.
It was like I expected…the worst parts were worse, and it was harder to appreciate the parts that I did like. That’s not to say that I didn’t, of course. Will Poulter always has been, and always will be, the perfect Eustace to me. I think the saddest part about no more Narnia films (at least in this current incarnation) is that we will never get to see what Will could have done with Eustace’s character in the subsequent films. He was a real gem that was found, and a bright spot in a murky film.
This film wasn’t bad, but it suffered from a very heavy-handed script and a complete lack of vision and focus when it came to the overall structure of the film.
For the one thousandth time, I couldn’t help but hang my head and wonder just how better this film could have been if it had had someone with a clear goal and focus. The whole Green Mist mess is to me a glaring result of this.
Look, folks. I’ve SEEN the early draft script. Non-Narnian fans have probably not heard about this, so I’ll summarize it briefly. Shortly after Prince Caspian was released, about twenty pages of the Dawn Treader draft script was leaked online. Production instantly scrambled and shutting it down, swearing up and down that the script was very, very old and was nothing like what the finished product would be. They lied. :p The script contained all of the Green Mist elements and several other new additions, including Gale and Ramandu’s Daughter being a Blue Star.
The thing was, this draft script had been written with the plan to make both Dawn Treader and the Silver Chair back-to-back and connect their stories. It still had the Green Mist, but it was the work of the SC’s main adversary, the Lady of the Green Kirtle. She was the clear instigator, and the whole plot revolved around her kidnapping Narnians to raise up an army, and the Dawn Treader crew going after the Green Mist in order to get them back.
But when the whole Disney/Fox situation happened, the decision was made to cut all connections to the Silver Chair and instead keep Dawn Treader within it’s own parameters, in case they never made any more films. The problem was, they cut out the Lady of the Green Kirtle, but they didn’t cut out the Green Mist or the kidnappings, or “sacrifices.” THIS, in my opinion, was what sunk this film, not the concept itself. Without the Silver Chair’s villainess as the main driving force of the film, it left all the elements without any real purpose or meaning. It cheapened the whole plot and left a lot of people scratching their heads.
Sure, the leaked script was pretty blasphemous in how it strayed from the original book. But at least it had the making of a well-rounded, thought-out film. In my very humble opinion, it’s more of a disgrace to C.S. Lewis and the books to make a poor film that is sort of faithful and sort of not, then to make a really great film that’s more unfaithful but a good story. Just saying.
ANYWAY. All that aside. The whole Green Mist thing was harder to watch this time around just because I kept thinking, what if, what if, what if. It’s such a shame that Narnia didn’t get a production crew that was really dedicated to having the film’s best interests at heart. It, and we, deserved more than that.
But enough about what I didn’t like. There were still things that I did like! I already mentioned Eustace. Another thing that really stood out to me was the amazing production design and visuals. I still stand behind the Dawn Treader as being one of the most cinematically stunning films I’ve seen. All the camera work and set design was just amazing. Some shots really take your breath away, especially at the end. I think the scene where Edmund, Lucy and Eustace go through the water tunnel was one of the best bits of 3D cinematography I’ve ever seen.
Which brings us to the end of the film.
I was completely shocked when I found myself in tears during the scene where the Pevensies tell Aslan goodbye. I had misted up during this scene the first time I saw it, but this was the full-on waterworks display. I didn’t think that after all this time, I’d still find that scene emotional.
I don’t think it was just that particular scene, though. Because while Lucy and Edmund were saying good-bye to Narnia for the last time, so was I.
As most of you probably know, the Narnia film rights have been allowed to expire. I’m not exactly sure what the status on that is, but it will be some amount of time before the C.S. Lewis estate will have control of them again and will decide if they want to start shopping around for a new production company to re-start the franchise. I have complete faith that I’ll see more Narnia films in my lifetime; maybe as soon as five years or so. I mean, look how astonishingly fast the Spider-Man franchise was re-booted…it was barely three years. The C.S. Lewis estate has expressed their strong desire to see all seven of the Narnia books made into films, and they were already looking at possibly making and adaptation of the Magician’s Nephew before Fox and Walden Media pulled out. I think the Magician’s Nephew would be the perfect film to reboot the franchise on at some point, and even if they don’t want to do that particular book, you know how Hollywood is so remake happy these days. I KNOW I’ll see at least one more film version of the Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe someday…I just know it.
That being said, even though I have faith that I’ll see more Narnia films someday, Dawn Treader marked the end of this particular Narnia film venture. They will make more movies, but it won’t be the same. It will be with a new cast, new crew, new websites and people to share it with.
I don’t think I’d ever really gotten closure with the fact that these particular days were now over, and that’s why it sort of hit me a little hard when I watched Dawn Treader today. No matter what your opinions on the Narnia films are, they were a big part of my life for the last six years. They got me through some rough transitions in my life, and helped spark several hobbies and passions that I still enjoy today, namely graphic making, website design and management, and creative writing.
The Narnia films have been the source of some pretty amazing experiences for me. I got to go to Comic-Con in ’07, where I represented Narniaweb and participated in a FAQ session at the Prince Caspian panel in front of six thousand people. I got to attend the Prince Caspian Lion Party at the El Capitan theater in Hollywood, California, and met some of my fellow Narniawebbers for the first time. Thanks to my website, I was able to receive an advanced copy of the Prince Caspian DVD, and also a free download of the Dawn Treader book app. I was able to to attend an advance screening of Dawn Treader, again representing Narniaweb. And last December, I had the privilege of hosting the official Chicago Lion Party.
If there hadn’t been any Narnia movies, I probably would not have started a website. Spareoom.net has been one of the biggest unexpected successes in recent years. I often would sit back and go over my site stats, stunned at how such a tiny, thrown-together site could be getting such traffic. It garnered me quite a lot of attention in the Narnia world, and remains one of the top Narnia fan sites on the Internet today. I’m still not sure how that happened, but it did.
Thanks to these movies, I’ve been able to connect with and meet some of the most amazing people. These are my fellow members and moderators on Narniaweb, and they are the greatest bunch of people you could find. They always have been there to provide support during a rough time, and to cheer you on during a success. I’ve had the absolute pleasure of being able to meet many of the people that I’ve gotten to know well online these last six years, and I know that we’re going to remain in touch for years to come.
So, with all that in mind, tonight was the night that I finally made my peace and really felt like I said good-bye to the Narnia franchise in this particular incarnation. It was an amazing, amazing run. It produced three films, including a film that one of my favorite of all time, Prince Caspian. Now THAT was a great film…it ranks in my top-ten of favorite films I’ve seen, ever. The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe and Dawn Treader were good too, but Prince Caspian just hit the right spot.
So, thank you, Narnia, for these last six years. I know I’ll see you again someday. And in the meantime, I still have the amazing books to read and enjoy, and all these remembrances to cherish.
Thanks for the memories!









The Muppets
Sherlock Holmes – A Game of Shadows
The Adventures of Tintin
The Iron Lady
John Carter
Mirror, Mirror
The Hunger Games







